From the very beginning, one could tell Old John’s was different. Yes, it sold delicious comfort food at affordable prices but that's not what made it special. The staff, many of whom have been there for ten to twenty-plus years treated you like family.
They know your name. They greet you with a warm smile. They don’t simply wait on you… they welcome you into the home away from home that is Old John’s. They make you feel like family. Old John’s is truly a jewel in the crown of The Upper West Side.
Kathy Dellinger (22 Years at Old John's)