Apple, cinnamon pancakes

Holiday PIe Special

Firefly_replace+the+tabel+with+%23fdc57b+with+studio+light+shadow+background+766131.png

Plate with French fries, ketchup, pickle spear, and a veggie burger with greens and tomato on a seeded bun

Close-up of an eggs Benedict breakfast dish with poached eggs, ham, and hollandaise sauce, served with roasted potatoes on a white plate.

Dinner at Old John's

A slice of cheesecake with strawberry topping on a white plate with green and black rim, against a blue and light green background.

A glass bowl with three scoops of ice cream topped with a cherry and chopped nuts, served with banana slices on a paper placemat in a dessert shop or café.

Grilled salmon with asparagus, rice, lemon wedge, and sautéed onions on a white plate with green stripes.

Bartender preparing a cocktail with a lime wedge in a glass filled with ice, behind a bar with various bottles and bar tools.

Burger with lettuce, tomato, and a grilled patty in a seeded bun, served with French fries, a pickle spear, and ketchup on a plate.

A person is pouring syrup from a glass bottle onto a milkshake topped with whipped cream and a pink striped straw on a marble countertop.

A table set with three plates of food, including burgers with fries, steamed broccoli, mashed potatoes with gravy, and a plate with mixed vegetables and meatloaf, along with drinks, salt and pepper shakers, and utensils.

Thanksgiving pies

A plate with cooked broccolini and a hash brown topped with a green pepper on a restaurant table with a fork, knife, and napkin, and a menu beneath the plate.

Welcome to Old John's

Our Menus

Our Story

Old John’s has been part of the Upper West Side’s heartbeat since 1951.

Where mornings begin, stories are shared, friendships are made, and countless memories linger long after the plates are cleared.

Old John’s — serving elevated comfort, timeless tradition, and genuine hospitality since 1951.

Reserve Your Table